August 8, 2015

How a fairly normal-looking woman would look styled in the manner of various distinctive fashion/makeup photoshoots.

Nathalie Croquet does a great job with this, not overdoing critique of the fashion and beauty industry. She says "I feel people need a more spiritual approach to life, and good fun. I’m happy to give them that, even if I’m just making fun of myself."

She's French, by the way.

I like that she finds the good and the ridiculous in the different looks. It's clear that some commercial approaches to beauty and fashion can be adapted and used to good effect by a "normal" woman walking around in the real word (Lancome, Voltaire, Eric Bompard, Paule Ka, Givenchy) and some things only work on a model who is posed and lit in a fantasy setting (Etam, Acne Studios). Of course, it's always funny to copy the poses and expressions of models. I feel that I've seen that many times, but this is a nice example of that genre of comedy.

18 comments:

Sydney said...

Whenever I go to the makeup counter and let one of the "artists" do a makeover on me, I end up looking like the "normal" woman in those photos.

tim maguire said...

When you see what goes into producing a style photo, you realize the end result is a cartoon. I don't know why they even bother with models.

Robert said...

Ageist?

MacMacConnell said...

I didn't read the article, but the photos were fun.

Phil 314 said...

"French fashion stylist"

Isn't she biting hand that feeds her?

Nichevo said...

I don't think those sweaters are the same shade of pink or red or whatever. Not guilty!

Paco Wové said...

It's not just 'normal woman vs. fashion model'. There's also a considerable age difference between Mme. Croquet and the models. Some fashions (and poses) just don't look good on older women – "mutton dressed as lamb" is a thing, after all – and some fashions don't look good on anyone.

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

Art is a lie that tells the truth but sometimes the truth is kind of ugly.

Freeman Hunt said...

I loved this. I love her attention to detail in copying the photographs.

Anonymous said...

Paco: It's not just 'normal woman vs. fashion model'. There's also a considerable age difference between Mme. Croquet and the models. Some fashions (and poses) just don't look good on older women – "mutton dressed as lamb" is a thing, after all – and some fashions don't look good on anyone.

Yup. She's too old for every one of those looks. (Some people can't seem to imagine anything between or beyond "junior department" and "old frump"; the concept of adult elegance seems to have been lost entirely. Not that designers or retailers are helping.)

buwaya said...

The series is well done. But Paco is right, the big deal here is age. Most of these shots would be much less absurd if the "normal" woman was an average lass in her teens and twenties.
I get it that the fashion market is older women for the most part, which is a bit sad.

Unknown said...

Is Mme. Croquet as old as a certain Jenner?

Ann Althouse said...

It's so important when looking at fashion/beauty photographs to figure out whether it looks good mainly or only because the model is young and very good or interesting looking. Some photos are striking because the stuff on the model is so horrible that it's amazing the model was able to present it as appealing.

Ann Althouse said...

I'm getting tired of seeing women on TV wearing eyeliner on the inner lower lid like Penelope Cruz in that Lancome ad. I can see why women who put it on think it's great, but I think soon if not already, it's going to look dated and we will wonder why women ever did that.

It's possibly bugging me especially since I just got a higher definition television. As Bob Dylan once sang, now people just get uglier...

George Grady said...

I find myself inexplicably disappointed that she got one of the dominoes wrong in the Lanvin ad.

el polacko said...

it's obvious why these "normal" women are not models: fat, old, and ugly doesn't sell product.

Scott M said...

Then. Stop. Doing. It. Men do not read these things.

Nichevo said...

Hm. I wonder if this is douchey.